| POS | Player | Team |
| QB | Peyton Manning | DEN |
| RB | Arian Foster | HOU |
| RB | Adrian Peterson | MIN |
| WR | Brandon Marshall | CHI |
| WR | Calvin Johnson | DET |
| WR | AJ Green | CIN |
| TE | Rob Gronkowski | NE |
| Kicker | Stephen Gostowski | NE |
| Defense | Broncos | DEN |
Elite-9: 2012