| POS | Player | Team |
| QB | Peyton Manning | IND |
| RB | Chris Johnson | TEN |
| RB | Adrian Peterson | MIN |
| WR | Larry Fitzgerald | ARZ |
| WR | Randy Moss | NE |
| WR | Reggie Wayne | IND |
| TE | Vernon Davis | SF |
| Kicker | Stephen Gostkowski | NE |
| Defense | Denver Broncos | DEN |
Elite-9: 2009