| POS | Player | Team |
| QB | Peyton Manning | IND |
| RB | LaDainian Tomlinson | SD |
| RB | Shuan Alexander | SEA |
| WR | Steve Smith | CAR |
| WR | Santana Moss | WAS |
| WR | Chad Johnson | CIN |
| TE | Antonio Gates | SD |
| Kicker | Neil Rackers | ARZ |
| Defense | Bears | CHI |
Elite-9: 2005